UKaid

So did you hear you can watch TV on computers now? Sometimes not even when it’s showing on the TV but later? You go to a TV channel’s website like BBC iPlayer and there’s all this stuff there. Crazy times we live in, eh? Which is a luddite way of saying I watched some of “Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution” the other day. Though I know it’s a couple of years old and you’re probably completely over it. Nevertheless: has anyone thought of showing this in first year university lectures on International Development? Or in high schools? It’s a wonderful demonstration and a highly accessible object lesson for an inexpert audience.

Seriously, look at it – Well Meaning White Fella goes into impoverished town in another country and tells the poor fools what’s good for them. Literally in this case. Lots of celery I think. But unlike tramping into the Wilds Of Africa, Jamie shares a language with these poor Americans, albeit with a funny accent. He basically looks like one of them. He and his beneficiaries have an enormous amount of shared culture and history; I bet they can talk about their favourite Simpsons episodes together. He comes with fame and facts and funds at his disposal.

With all these advantages, short-cuts and leg-ups, it is nevertheless a real slog of wading through school canteen bureaucracy, sucking up to petty tyrant local politicians and influence peddlers, winning over hearts and minds, dressing up like a twerp in some kind of celery costume (hello, Public Health Promoters!) and spending hours and hours with household level beneficiaries. And despite the schmaltz and strings and success stories and sobbing to camera, strip away the scripted-for-TV narrative arc and you can’t help thinking that in the end, the impact has been pretty minimal, the locals really don’t give much of a toss, and as soon as he leaves will go back to eating choco-puff krispies and Big Mac pizzas for breakfast washed down with hot cups of runny lard.

The learning point for our eager beaver rich-world development studies students: what makes you think that doing the same between countries and cultures and communities far more radically different than the US and UK is going to be easy or quick or straightforward in any way? Why is the foreigner there in the first place? When you watch this, who are you in this story? Why do you like this narrative? If you can come up with valid reasons for there to be a  ‘Jamie’, what gives you the right to think that you’re the one to do it? What are you really going to bring to the table?

Hello. Sorry. I’ll try to blog more.

About these ads


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 50 other followers